Skip to content

Rethinking Loyalty in the Age of Experiences

by Lindsey Buxman
Phygital Marketing
April 29, 2026

Contents

Rethinking Loyalty in the Age of Experiences

‍

Loyalty programs have traditionally operated on a simple premise: Spend more, earn more.

‍

Customers accumulate points, unlock discounts, and receive rewards for shopping with a brand. It's a familiar model, and one that can be effective at encouraging repeat purchases.

‍

But what happens when customers want more from their relationship with a brand than another discount?

‍

On a recent episode of The Phygital Marketing Podcast, I sat down with customer analytics and loyalty strategist Ian Dewar, whose experience includes leading loyalty and customer strategy initiatives at The North Face and Anthropologie.

‍

Our conversation explored how loyalty programs are evolving, why physical retail remains essential to customer discovery, and how digital tools can make the in-store experience more valuable.

‍

Loyalty Has Three Different Dimensions

‍

Ian approaches loyalty through three distinct categories: transactional, convenience-based, and experiential.

‍

Transactional loyalty is the traditional rewards model. Customers earn points, discounts, or other incentives based on how much or how frequently they purchase. It gives people a financial reason to return.

‍

Convenience-based loyalty makes engaging with a brand easier. Ian pointed to Hertz Gold as an example, where members can bypass the rental counter and go directly to their cars. The value isn't necessarily another reward. It's the time and effort saved.

‍

Experiential loyalty gives customers access to something they might not otherwise receive, such as exclusive events, early product launches, special experiences, or limited-edition merchandise.

‍

Ian believes experiential loyalty is where the industry is heading.

‍

He saw that evolution firsthand while working on The North Face's VIPeak Rewards program. What began as a largely points-driven program increasingly incorporated experiences that connected customers to the brand beyond their purchases.

‍

That doesn't mean points are disappearing. Ian still sees value in straightforward financial rewards. But experiences give customers additional reasons to engage, even when they aren't ready to buy something.

‍

A Store Visit Without a Purchase Isn't Necessarily a Failure

‍

One of the most interesting moments in the conversation came when Ian challenged how retailers think about conversion.

‍

Brands naturally want shoppers to make purchases. But not every customer enters a store intending to buy something that day.

‍

Some are comparing products. Others are discovering a brand for the first time, trying something on, or exploring what's new.

‍

Ian argued that these visits shouldn't automatically be considered missed opportunities.

‍

A customer who spends time exploring a collection or learning about a product may be developing a stronger connection to the brand, even if the transaction happens weeks later.

‍

That creates an important role for experiential loyalty.

‍

In-store events, product demonstrations, exclusive access, and other engaging experiences can give customers reasons to visit beyond an immediate purchase.

‍

For retailers, the opportunity is to recognize the value of those interactions and find ways to continue the relationship after the customer leaves.

‍

The Customer Journey Doesn't Follow a Straight Line

‍

Ian also discussed how dramatically the shopping journey has changed.

‍

A customer might discover a product on social media, research it on their phone, compare options on a desktop, and eventually visit a store to see it in person.

‍

Another customer might walk past a storefront, discover something interesting, and continue exploring it online later.

‍

These aren't separate online and offline audiences. They're customers moving between channels based on what they need at a particular moment.

‍

Ian sees retail apps as potentially valuable companions throughout that process.

‍

He described using Home Depot's app to locate products inside a store, check inventory, and find alternative purchasing options. Rather than replacing the physical experience, the app makes it easier to navigate.

‍

He also pointed to the value of digital tools that help customers compare sizes, styles, and colors while shopping in person.

‍

The lesson isn't that every retailer needs more technology. It's that digital tools should help customers move through the shopping experience without unnecessary friction.

‍

Discovery Looks Different for Every Brand

‍

Not every customer walks into a store with the same mindset.

‍

Ian contrasted his experiences at The North Face and Anthropologie to illustrate how differently people shop.

‍

At The North Face, customers often arrive with a specific need. They might be looking for a rain jacket, hiking boots, or equipment for an upcoming trip.

‍

At Anthropologie, shopping is frequently more exploratory.

‍

Ian recalled research conducted with Anthropologie customers who often explained that they hadn't known what they wanted until they saw it in the store.

‍

That difference has important implications for personalization.

‍

For a customer shopping with a specific goal, helpful recommendations might include complementary products, inventory information, or guidance that makes the purchase easier.

‍

For someone browsing, personalization might mean introducing products, collections, or experiences they wouldn't have discovered otherwise.

‍

In both cases, understanding how and why customers shop matters as much as knowing what they've purchased before.

‍

Bringing Loyalty Into the Real World

‍

The conversation highlights an opportunity for retailers to think about loyalty as something customers experience throughout their relationship with a brand, rather than simply a program they participate in at checkout.

‍

Rewards can encourage purchases. Convenience can make shopping easier. Experiences can create reasons to visit, explore, and engage.

‍

And when physical and digital interactions work together, those relationships can continue across channels.

‍

At Sotto, we see particular value in helping brands turn real-world interactions into opportunities for ongoing customer engagement. In-store experiences can create meaningful connections, while digital touchpoints can help those relationships continue beyond the visit.

‍

Ian's perspective is a reminder that the most effective loyalty strategies aren't necessarily the ones offering the most points.

‍

They're the ones giving customers compelling reasons to keep coming back.

‍

Watch the full conversation with Ian Dewar on The Phygital Marketing Podcast.

‍